St. Mary's Church

Welcome to St. Mary's Beauly

Reflection on the readings for the 23rd Sunday in Ordinary Time – click to view

Dear brothers and sisters in Christ, we live in an age of extraordinary communication. Within seconds, we can send a message across the world, post an opinion online or tell hundreds of people what somebody has done. Yet, strangely we are becoming less able to speak honestly and lovingly to one another. When someone hurts us, it can be easier to speak about them than to speak to them. Today, the Word of God challenges this culture and teaches us something profoundly Christian: if we truly love someone, we cannot be indifferent to what is destroying them or our relationship with them.

In the first reading, God tells Ezekiel, “I have appointed you as sentry to the House of Israel.” Ezekiel exercised his prophetic ministry during one of Israel’s darkest periods, around the time of the Babylonian exile in the sixth century BC. Jerusalem had fallen, the people were displaced and the nation was living with the consequences of years of unfaithfulness. God tells Ezekiel that being a prophet means more than comforting people; sometimes he must warn them. If he sees danger and remains silent, he shares responsibility for what happens. That message is uncomfortable today because we live in a society that often says, “It is their life; leave them alone.” Certainly, Christianity does not give us permission to interfere arrogantly in everybody’s affairs. But neither does love permit complete indifference. Parents cannot watch their children moving towards destruction and say nothing. Friends should not watch friends ruin themselves through addiction, dishonesty or destructive choices and remain silent. And the Church cannot abandon difficult truths simply because society finds them uncomfortable.

But how we speak the truth matters enormously. That is why St. Paul gives us the key in the 2nd reading: “Owe no one anything, except to love one another.” St. Paul was writing to Christians in Rome, a diverse community learning how Jews and Gentiles, people of different backgrounds and social positions could live together as one body in Christ. His answer is love. Not sentimental love but a love that genuinely seeks another person’s good. Christian correction without love becomes condemnation but love without truth can become mere sentimentality.

Jesus brings both together beautifully in the Gospel. St. Matthew was writing for a Christian community that already knew the reality of disagreement, sin and conflict within the Church. Jesus therefore gives them a practical process: “If your brother does something wrong, go and have it out with him alone.” Notice the word alone. Jesus does not say, “Tell your friends first.” He does not say, “Put it on Facebook.” He does not say, “Create a WhatsApp group and discuss what an awful person he is.” He says: go to the person. The purpose is not humiliation but restoration: “If he listens to you, you have won back your brother.” Imagine how different our families, parishes, workplaces and communities would become if we actually practised this Gospel. Many relationships are destroyed not by the original offence but by what happens afterwards: gossip, assumptions, screenshots, silent treatment, taking sides and refusing to speak directly to one another. Jesus offers another way. Speak privately first. If that fails, involve one or two wise people. Only afterwards should the wider community become involved. In other words: protect the dignity of the person while seeking the truth.

Perhaps this Sunday we should each ask ourselves: Is there someone I have been talking about whom I really need to talk to? Is there someone whose wrongdoing I excuse because I am afraid of losing their friendship? Is there someone I have condemned without first listening to their side? And perhaps the most difficult question: when someone corrects me, can I listen?

The Psalm warns us: “O that today you would listen to his voice! Harden not your hearts.” Sometimes God’s voice comes through the very person we would rather not hear. Jesus concludes: “Where two or three meet in my name, I shall be there with them.” Christ is present wherever people choose reconciliation over revenge, truth over gossip, listening over accusation and love over pride.

This week, therefore, let us become watchmen for one another but watchmen motivated by love. Let us have the courage to speak when necessary, the humility to listen when corrected and the grace to forgive when wounded. Because sometimes the greatest proof that we love someone is not that we always agree with them but that we care enough to tell the truth, gently enough to preserve their dignity and love them enough to seek reconciliation. Amen.

Fr. Max & Fr. James, who reside at St. Mary’s Beauly, serve the communities of…

Diocese of Aberdeen

Wider Church

Catholic News